I need a shoe makeover and I need your help!!!! I really need a new pair of black dress shoes for a wedding coming up in September. And I'd like something that will take me throught the winter. But I'm having a couple problems.....

1.) I have about size 8, fat squatty feet and a not-so-svelt body. So I sometimes feel that I don't look good in dress shoes.

2.) I am very picky about my shoes being comfortable and am not into wearing very high heels. I can handle about 2-3 inches.

3.) I have a fear of buying shoes online. The only shoes I've ever bought online are crocs. I'm typically a PayLess kind of girl. (Don't judge me! )

Can anyone help or offer advice? I'd like to take advantage of the ShoeBuy deal right now, but I just don't know what to get.