I take a 5½. Should I order up or down for the Crocs Cleo?


I ordered the Crocs Prima a few weeks ago and ordered a 5 and they fit fine. A little snug but someone said they will stretch.

I have a pair of Waldies Aurba (similar shape to Crocs Cleo) and on those I ordered a size up (6) and they are fine.

I really like the Waldies but the Crocs Cleo are $5.00 cheaper. Then with the SR coupon and my member discount and the 13% back.....it makes it even more attractive. Not to mention free shipping!

Thanks for any help!