I've been reading the reviews on allears, too, and they are also mixed. People seem to either love it or hate it. DH and I are big foodies, too, and neither is at all picky. So unless the food is horrid, I'm sure we'll love it. If nothing else just for the experience and ambiance. I am more about atmosphere than the food at restaurants more often than not! A place can have the best food in the world but if the atmosphere is "blah" it won't get a good review from me. (Disney has sure spoiled me for other restaurants with no themeing!)